EXPLAIN Analyzer

Static rules can tell you a query looks risky. Only the database can tell you it is: that the WHERE you wrote hits no index, that the planner chose a sequential scan over ten million rows, that the ORDER BY needs a filesort. sqlguard explain asks the planner and reports what it finds — without ever executing the query.

Usage

# PostgreSQL
sqlguard explain --db "postgres://app:secret@localhost/app?sslmode=disable" \
    "SELECT id, total FROM orders WHERE customer_id = 42"

# MySQL / MariaDB
sqlguard explain --dialect mysql --db "app:secret@tcp(localhost:3306)/app" \
    "SELECT id, total FROM orders WHERE customer_id = 42"

# JSON for tooling
sqlguard explain --db "…" --format json "SELECT …"

Flag	Default	Effect
--db <dsn>	required	Connection string. Postgres DSNs use pgx's postgres:// URL or key=value form; MySQL uses go-sql-driver/mysql DSN syntax.
--dialect postgres|mysql	postgres	Which planner to talk to. MariaDB works through mysql.
--format console|json	console	Output shape.
--allow-dml	off	Permit INSERT / UPDATE / DELETE. Still planned only, still rolled back.
--config, --no-config	—	Persistent flags; explain findings are not affected by rules: config.

The whole command runs under a 30-second timeout, including the initial connectivity check. Exit code is 1 when the plan has issues, 0 when clean.

As with scan, the console rendering goes to stderr and --format json goes to stdout, always as an array. Changed in 0.3. In 0.2 JSON went to stderr, so redirecting it produced an empty file.

[SQLGUARD WARNING] seq-scan
  Query: SELECT id, total FROM orders WHERE customer_id = 42
  Issue: Sequential scan detected (estimated 812430 rows, cost 21877.5)
  Fix:   Consider adding an index to avoid full table scan.

[SQLGUARD WARNING] high-cost
  Query: SELECT id, total FROM orders WHERE customer_id = 42
  Issue: High cost operation: Seq Scan (cost 21877.5)
  Fix:   Review query plan and consider optimization.

2 issue(s) found in query plan

Unlike every other surface, Query here is the raw text you typed — there is no log sink to protect, and you need to recognise your own query. Fingerprint is still set. See Redaction.

What it detects

Rule	Dialect	Fires on
seq-scan	postgres	A Seq Scan node. INFO at ≤ 1,000 estimated rows, WARNING above.
high-cost	postgres	Any node with Total Cost > 10,000.
full-table-scan	mysql	A row with access type = ALL.
no-index-used	mysql	A row with empty key and empty possible_keys.
filesort	mysql	Using filesort in Extra.

Postgres plans are requested as EXPLAIN (FORMAT JSON) and walked recursively, so nested scans inside joins and CTEs are found. MySQL plans are requested as EXPLAIN FORMAT=TRADITIONAL — MySQL 9 defaults @@explain_format to TREE, which is a single free-text column — and read by column name, because MariaDB emits 10 columns where MySQL emits 12. UNION RESULT and derived-table rows (<union1,2>, <derived2>) are skipped: they name temporary tables that have no index by construction.

If the server returns a plan shape the analyzer does not recognise — a missing expected column, say — it fails with an error rather than reporting "no issues". A plan checker that says clean when it could not look is worse than one that says so.

Safety model

EXPLAIN cannot take bind parameters, so the query text is necessarily concatenated into the EXPLAIN statement. The defense is layered and does not rely on parameterization:

1. Validation. Empty input is refused. Multi-statement input is refused using a comment- and string-literal-aware check (analyzer.IsMultiStatement), so a ; hidden in a -- comment, a /* */ block or a string cannot smuggle a second statement. That check takes the narrowest reading of a string literal — the opposite of Redact, which takes the widest. The two have opposite fail-safe directions: redaction must never leave a literal byte in its output, while this check must never miss a separator, so 'a\'; DROP TABLE t; --' is refused rather than read as one literal. The statement is then classified with the fallback parser: SELECT / WITH pass; INSERT / UPDATE / DELETE pass only with --allow-dml; DDL, SET, transaction control and anything unrecognised are always refused.

   Changed in 0.3. The separator check previously scanned with a single reading of $$, which let some stacked input through. It now counts a ; as a separator whenever any dialect reading leaves it outside a literal, because each reading of $$ is blind to a different payload. Scanning $tag$…$tag$ as a literal is what hides the ; in UPDATE t AS $$ SET id = 1; DROP TABLE t — on MySQL those are identifier bytes, but that reading opens an unterminated dollar body which swallows the rest. Leaving $$ as ordinary bytes is what hides the ; in SELECT $$'$$; DROP TABLE t — on PostgreSQL the apostrophe is data inside the dollar body, but that reading opens an unterminated ordinary literal which swallows the rest. Each catches what the other misses, so both run. The cost is that a single statement carrying a ; inside a dollar-quoted body, such as SELECT $$a ; b$$, is refused; a one-statement query occasionally rejected is the safe error here.

2. A transaction that is always rolled back. Every EXPLAIN runs inside BeginTx with a deferred Rollback. Nothing commits.

3. Never ANALYZE. EXPLAIN ANALYZE executes the statement to collect real timings; sqlguard never uses it. The statement is planned, only.

The transaction is additionally opened read-only everywhere except MySQL/MariaDB under --allow-dml. Those servers reject every statement in a READ ONLY transaction with error 1792 — including an EXPLAIN that only plans a DML statement — so there the guarantee rests on the three layers above. This is deliberate; it is not a gap.

Library use

The CLI is a thin wrapper over the explain package, which works with any *sql.DB:

import "github.com/KARTIKrocks/sqlguard/explain"

pa, err := explain.New(db, "postgres")              // or "mysql"
pa, err = explain.New(db, "mysql", explain.WithAllowDML())

res, err := pa.Analyze(ctx, "SELECT id FROM orders WHERE customer_id = 42")
for _, issue := range res.Issues {                 // []analyzer.Result
    fmt.Println(issue.RuleName, issue.Message)
}
fmt.Println(res.RawPlan)                           // the plan text, for humans

explain.Result carries Query, RawPlan and Issues. Pair it with a test that runs your hottest queries through Analyze against a seeded database — a seq-scan on the orders table is cheaper to find in CI than at 3 a.m.

Drivers

Changed in 0.3. The CLI links github.com/jackc/pgx/v5/stdlib and github.com/go-sql-driver/mysql, so sqlguard explain works out of the box. Only the cmd/sqlguard package imports them; a library consumer of analyzer or middleware never compiles them in. In 0.2 the released binary shipped without a driver and explain could not connect.